A session to explore the unconscious from the mind of its inventor
Curriculum reference: Final Year Philosophy Program — Consciousness / The Unconscious
Total time: 45 minutes
Present Freud in 1900: he has just published The Interpretation of Dreams, he is a neurologist in Vienna, psychoanalysis is still a marginal idea. He deeply believes in his theory. Crucial reminder: he is unaware of the criticisms that will come.
Students question Freud on his fundamental concepts. Encourage questions on concrete cases (dreams, slips, phobias) rather than overly abstract questions. Freud likes clinical examples. The teacher can propose a fictitious 'case' to submit to Freud.
What does Freud defend? What are his arguments? What objections can already be formulated since 1900? Construct the two Freudian topographies on the board. What questions does Freud have difficulty answering convincingly?
Is psychoanalysis a science? An art? A philosophy? Students take a position in one argued sentence. Open up to Popper and the criterion of falsifiability if the level allows.
12 questions ready to use in class — students can also come up with their own.
How did you discover the existence of the unconscious? Where does this idea come from?
What happens in the unconscious when we sleep?
What is repression? How does it work concretely?
Does a slip always reveal something hidden? Give me an example.
How do you distinguish what comes from the unconscious and what comes from conscious thought?
Can psychoanalysis heal? What are the limits of your method?
Your theories on infantile sexuality have shocked many people. How do you explain these reactions?
Does the Oedipus complex really concern all children, in all cultures?
What do you say to those who claim you project your own obsessions into your theories?
Can one analyze someone without their cooperation? Can one analyze oneself?
In what way is your approach fundamentally different from philosophy and medicine?
In a hundred years, do you think psychoanalysis will still be practiced and respected?
From your teacher area, duplicate this activity to adapt it: add your own teaching documents (PDF, textbook extract…) — Sigmund Freud will rely on them and quote the exact passage to the student — and choose a reliability level for the AI: Restricted, Semi-restricted or Open. A blank student worksheet, without the answers, can still be printed separately for the lesson.
Create my custom version →Sigmund Freud answers your students' questions in real time. Nothing to install, no subscription to get started.
Start for free →